# Current State — v22 (Updated 2026-07-10 18:04)

## Stage
V9_BEST_FINAL_PACKAGE_FROZEN ✅

## Kimi Score Progression
| Version | Score | Change | Key Improvement |
|---------|-------|--------|----------------|
| v1 | 69/100 | baseline | First runnable version |
| v2 | 72/100 | +3 | Caption bar + scheduler log |
| v3 | 81/100 | **+9** | Bigger fonts + micro-animations + pulse + pacing |
| v4 | 85/100 | +4 | Ultra polish: hook, FAIL→FIX→PASS, font +20% |
| v5 | 86/100 | +1 | Opening montage, complete narrative chain |
| v6 | 89/100 | +3 | Subtitle -64%, duration -60%, 14→5 subs, bottom safety zone |
| v7 | 90/100 | +1 | xfade transition + subtitle color/opacity + Hook density |
| **v9** | **92/100** | **+2** | **制作痕迹清除: 顶部元数据/底部硬编码/结尾内部标签剥离** |
| v10 | **76/100** | **↘ -16** | **REGRESSION: 3/3 agents hardcoded bug + hook black screen** |
| v11 | 88/100 | +12 (fix) | Fixed v10 bugs, but 88 < 92, not surpassing v9 |

## V9 Wins
- ✅ 制作痕迹全部清除 — 零录屏、零截图、全程序化渲染
- ✅ Claude Code 真实界面感 10/10
- ✅ FAIL→FIX→PASS 叙事完整性 10/10
- ✅ 总体发布可用性 10/10 — 直接可发布
- ✅ **冻结为 final package — 当前最高分版本**

## V10/V11 Lessons
- ❌ 硬编码是零容忍 bug ("3/3 agents" while showing 4)
- ❌ V11 仅修复了 V10，未超越 V9 (88 < 92)
- ❌ 创新不能以回归为代价
- ✅ **后续如继续，必须从 V9 分支复制 V12**

## Final Decision
V9 (92/100) 是当前最高分版本。V10 发生严重 regression (-16 分)，V11 修复至 88 但仍低于 V9。
冻结 V9 为最终 release package。后续优化需从 V9 fork。

## Learned
- 制作痕迹清除对发布可用性至关重要 (V9 10/10 vs V11 8/10)
- 硬编码必须零容忍 — 一个数字不一致即可毁掉可信度
- 11 轮迭代，1 次 regression，最终 +23 分 (69→92)
- V9 是唯一达到 "直接发布" 级别的版本

## Do NOT
- ❌ Freeze V11
- ❌ Continue from V11
- ❌ Overwrite V9 code with V10/V11
- ❌ Re-run Kimi on V10/V11
- ❌ Real screen recording